Sherman Moving & Storage Company
- USDOT number
- 719392 ↗
- MC number
- MC392645 ↗
- Phone
- (317) 784-5462
- Fleet
- 8 trucks · 6 drivers
- Safety (FMCSA)
- 1 inspection · 1 crash
- Service area
- Interstate moves
- Location
- 990 E NATIONAL AVENUE, Indianapolis, IN 46227
- In the registry since
- 1997 · 29 years
- FMCSA registration updated
- May 2024
Rating trend by year
Share of 1–5★ reviews per year, Google + Yelp combined (90 dated reviews)
Rating breakdown
Star-by-star breakdown above is based on the 90 reviews we've captured the full text of so far — out of 91 total reviews across Google & Yelp.
Customer reviews (91)
Wonderful job! The team worked quickly and no bumping into anything or damage. I would highly recommend!
What a wonderful experience. Professional, kind, and efficient crew/company. Will recommend and use again!
If you need movers, this is the company to call. The three gentlemen that moved me--New York Rob, Rob V, and Dakota--were so nice and very professional. I don't have expensive furniture but they treated all of my belongings with great care. They were very efficient, and before I knew it, they had em...
The whole experience was superb with them. - Sales Rep over the phone and emails was attentive and responded to our questions immediately. Very clear and efficient. - On-Field team led by Larry was outstanding. They took care of everything wanted and the provided several solutions for the packing an...
They arrived promptly. Very professional. Was very happy with the moving process from the start to the finish
The crew that moved me from Plainfield to Carmel today were fantastic. They arrived exactly when they said. They worked fast and efficiently. And we're a good group of guys. The whole process from first contact with the office for a quote was a great experience. Thanks to all.
We read this company's 19 lowest-rated reviews and sorted what they describe, unverified, as written by the reviewers. A type is listed once two or more reviewers describe it, and a review that describes two problems is counted in both rows. Quotes are the reviewers' own words.
Damaged or lost belongingsItems broken, lost or missing during the move
13 reviews · latest 2025
“broken head board, scratches on dining room table” 1★ · Google · Jun 2025 · Jeanene Walton · Read the review →
“they had done $2500. in damages and missing personal property.” 1★ · Yelp · Sep 2022 · Diana G. · See this company on Yelp →
“they did over $1700 worth of damages” 1★ · Google · Aug 2022 · Diana Garo · Read the review →
Bill higher than the quoteThe price went up on moving day or at delivery
7 reviews · latest 2024
“No written itemized explanation for nearly $1,500 increase in amount billed compared to quote” 2★ · Google · Apr 2024 · BeckyS · Read the review →
“Rather than taking only one day to move us they took 11/2 days raising the cost.” 1★ · Google · Dec 2023 · Robert Wheeler · Read the review →
“Not $4366 like they charged me” 1★ · Yelp · Sep 2022 · Diana G. · See this company on Yelp →
Damage claim denied or ignoredA claim was refused, ignored, or paid a fraction of the value
3 reviews · latest 2025
“After submitting a claim, Maura Mackey (owner/manager) refused to take my calls and refused to return a message.” 1★ · Google · Jan 2025 · Christopher Moravec · Read the review →
“However after submitting the claim, Maura Mackey (owner/manager) refused to take a call or to return a call” 1★ · Yelp · Jan 2025 · Christopher T. · See this company on Yelp →
These are customers' accounts, quoted as written. Problem types and sums are our reading of each review. We do not verify individual claims, and the company may dispute them. Counts cover the 19 low-rated reviews we read, not every review on Google or Yelp. Bars compare the types with each other.
Write a review
Log in to write a review →Profile views
Daily visits to this profile over the last 30 days (17 total)